Review: Scrapplings by Amelia Smith


3 stars

Read from October 02 to 12, 2015 — I own a copy

Synopsis: Darna shouldn’t have been born – priestesses aren’t supposed to have babies – and she most certainly shouldn’t see dragons. After all, no one else does, except in Anamat, or so the minstrels say.

She sets out for the city of Anamat. Along the way, she meets Myril, an older girl with frequent premonitions and an eerie sense of hearing.

Then there’s Iola, who is so dragon-struck that she actually wants to be a priestess. She’s blind to the corruption in the temples.

Thorat is Iola’s champion. He sees dragons as much as the girls do, but unlike them he blends easily in to a crowd.

Apart from these four, the city seems to be nearly as dragon-blind as the provinces. Darna scavenges for scraps, but apprenticeships cost more than she’s likely to earn. When she’s offered a sack of gold beads for a small bit of thieving, she takes her chances… and ends up angering the dragon herself.

Scrapplings is the first book in a five part series. Book Two, Priestess, is due out in April 2015.

Bookish Things: 324 pages. This is the first book of a 5 book series. The cover is simple, but the styling is kept for the series. Book #2 of the series has already been released.

Where to buy: Amazon on kindle for $3.53 or paperback for $13.95

My Review: 

This story reads like a 3rd or 4th draft. It’s almost there, but not quite finished.

The basics of the characters have been developed, but they still felt rather shallow. Like cardboard cut outs instead of real people. I could see the potential, but it wasn’t fully explored.

The concept of children begging and scrapping for junk felt like a good fit with the story, but I really couldn’t move past Iola’s annoying personality. I kept seeing something like this every time she was begging in the market place. So annoying! description

I am all for building the world and immersing the reader into it, but about 75% of this 324 page book felt like it was set aside for exploring the day-to-day minutiae, that really could have been summed up in a few days of exploration, not months. It started to get to this point…

One of the saving graces of this book is that there’s plenty of these little guys running/flying around…
I adore dragons, and I thought the dragon-sight was a unique and interesting concept. I would have appreciated more on that, as long as it wasn’t involving Iola.

The whole story reads as a Young Adult read, the characters are young teens and the tone and feel of the book all sit squarely inside that genre, with the exception of the interesting, but strange ‘ritual prostitution’ (thanks for that wording KJ!) that goes on in the temples.

Overall, I didn’t love any of the characters, though I’d have to say Thorat came into his own a little towards the end. Dorna was prickly and hard to like, and Myril just seemed a bit too much of a crutch that was used when a plot hole needed to be filled.

I am curious to know what happens next, but I’m not in a mad rush. I’m sure I’ll get around to picking up the next book sometime.

**Note: I was provided an electronic copy of this book in return for an honest review**


Please Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s